I wrote my last post just before heading home from work. On the way home, I did some cataloging homework, but just as we got into the city, I was getting too sleepy to focus, so I checked my email.
Smartphones are a blessing and a curse. First, the curse. I got the Facebook notification that someone else commented on aforementioned Catholic’s post about HHS, basically re-quoting Archbishop Dolan. Why is it everyone’s quoting Dolan? Why not anybody else? I’m starting to worry about a Dolan-groupie group-think. Just because he took offense, so did the USCCB. And because the USCCB took offense, all Catholics are required or felt obligated to repeat and support what the USCCB and Dolan says. I’m afraid he’ll be the first American Pope. Geez. That’s not a settling feeling.
Anyway, the person said that Humane Vitae said that any contraceptive use in marriage is inherently evil. ANY. Funny, I’ve heard from other places that it’s not the case. Married women can be treated for gynecologic disorders while enjoying the full benefits of being married, if you know what I mean.
You know what else Humane Vitae says? Many, including priests and theologians, have interpreted it to mean “reasonable treatment” but it said “cure.” The only cure for most gynecologic ddisorders would be a malpractice non-cure, that is, a full hysterectomy and ovarectomy. There’d be millions of people walking around without their uteruses and ovaries. There, that’ll solve the overpopulation. Ha.
You know what else the encyclical did? It drew a comparison between marital rape and contraception. Srsly.
It also drew conclusions that wasn’t even up to date with the reproductive science at the time. And science have further disproved many of the objections (namely, abortion.) It drew questionable theological conclusions, making a strange differentiation between NFP and contraception, even though both are made with full consent of both spouses with the moral intent of delaying pregnancy and spacing out children.The morality of various approaches to the same end can be discussed and questioned–only if they consider modern scientific discoveries in said discussion. New, unverified discoveries can be overlooked for the moment, but anything that seems to have consistent results no matter how many studies have been done…those need to be considered.
First off, I really do not understand the objection to medical treatment. It starts making people sound like the Christian Scientists or Jehovah’s Witnesses when they start denying effective and relatively inexpensive treatment for questionable religious purposes. Seriously, people are saying I can’t use Implanon solely because I’m married. I can be treated if we abstain from sex according to these people’s perspectives, but abstention is also a moral matter if we abstain for too long. So, therefore, married women can’t be treated. Nope. Nada.
Oh, don’t get into the whole PPVI Institute thing. Same hormones, different name. Just because it has the pope‘s name in the title doesn’t make it suddenly okay. I tried it. The Creighton Model with Hilgers’ additions is great–I was actually able to track and make some sense of my periods, even if they didn’t want to come. But when I went to see him with the required data later on, he was rude and dismissive–I presume because I wasn’t married yet, so he couldn’t help me conceive. The office repeatedly said that they could process it as a gynecological visit rather than infertility, when I checked in and out. Then they billed me for infertility anyway , and insurance didn’t cover it. Yeah, $100 was kind of painful. I never went back, and then later on I realized, hey, there are already meds with the exact same hormones. In PILL form! Cheaper! And I can go to a regular gynecologist! For cheaper! Turns out the med I needed was an implant, but it’s exactly the same thing as the shots from Hilgers so often promoted. ARGH.
So, married women like me whose uterus doesn’t want to shed its lining have to resort to just prayer to solve our condition, or opt for a full hysterectomy, which insurance probably won’t pay for because it could have been treated with a far cheaper medicine!
Okay. Rant over. My views are still in flux, but I’m recognizing more and more just how… how shall I phrase it…backwards Catholic theology and morality is compared to reproductive scientific discovery. Seriously, people are afraid of being treated for fear of hell. Or rejection by fellow Catholics.
Now, for the blessing of smartphones–just as I had finished reading the emailed notification, I realized that I was making absolutely the right decision. And a new email came in just then–and it was an email from the pastor at the cathedral, saying that was delightful news. There’s going to be a luncheon at the church on Sunday and both my husband and I are going–so she’ll talk to me then.
What a relief–seriously, perfect timing. I’d been a nervous, unsure person all week after I semi-sorta-kinda made a definitive decision to be EpiscoCatholic and hadn’t heard back after sending an email. Perhaps she was waiting until I made a definitive decision?
In any case, it will feel extraordinarily weird not to go to a Roman Catholic Mass this Sunday. Don’t get me wrong, I still love the parish I went to–but I just could no longer reconcile my beliefs with the Church’s, and to top it off, I felt like there was no place for me, a moderate.
But that’s the other blessing…I get to sleep in, because it’s a 11am Mass at the Episcopal Cathedral. Ha!
That’s the other thing that’ll feel weird. First time I receive Communion that’s other than Catholic. The wine’s different, too.
I’m sad, but I’m also very very glad.
Glad for my supportive husband and his family. Glad for my friends. Oddly enough, I especially appreciated the listening ear and the advice from my agnostic and atheist friends. My pagan friend is amazingly supportive. An ex-Catholic Christian helped me to realize that I’m not the only one who had difficulty reconciling with some of the Church’s teachings.
God bless them all. Even the agnostic and atheist friends–they were friends with me from the beginning of college, and managed to stick by me even when I was this really conservative shy Catholic who was rather narrow-minded, and stuck by me as my beliefs evolved. They’ve both said that it was fascinating watching me. Ha. I’m glad I can be of some entertainment to them :P